Not Just Laptops is supported by readers like you. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more.
Laptops are often the most natural choice for college students, but is that always the case? The latest tablets, especially iPads, can cause quite a dilemma when choosing a machine for your studies.
Should you opt for the portability, convenience, and form factor of an iPad or rely on the traditional capabilities of a laptop? Can a sleek tablet totally replace a student’s laptop?
In this article, we delve into the debate of iPad vs. laptop for college, looking at the strengths and limitations of both devices for everyday academic tasks.
Table of Contents
Comparing Laptop and iPad What You Need to Know
To see whether an iPad or laptop is better for your college needs, you’ll need to consider software, systems performance, device versatility, and budget.
Software
Software you run can be a deciding factor between an iPad and a laptop.
With dedicated apps like Chemistry X10, Complete Physics, or Human Anatomy Atlas, iPads are awesome for learning. Checking 3D images with explanation of human body parts is a great way to introduce more hands-on, interactive learning.
iPad has quality notetaking apps like Goodnote and Notability, and if you have Apple Pencil, that’s a great combo.
What I love about this software is that I can move handwritten notes and add content with Pencil — or color the crucial points and add visuals, easy-peasy.
However, a traditional laptop offers a better typing experience. The same is true for reading through PDF files.
Most majors require writing extensive papers, which is much easier on a traditional laptop with legacy desktop apps like MS Office. In this regard, software compatibility might be the most significant advantage of a computer.
While you can work around some limitations of iPad OS, software such as AutoCAD, Blender, and video/photo editing lacks full functionality. Programming is another field where you’d benefit more from a laptop.
iPad has quality notetaking apps like Goodnote and Notability, and if you have Apple Pencil, that’s a great combo.
Performance
We all know that sub-$500 laptops can obviously do less than $1000 models. In a similar vein, iPad 10th generation, iPad Air and iPad Pro are different devices, with Pro costing — and offering — considerably more.
Most iPads (excluding Pros) have fewer RAM and GBs of storage, but the system is designed to focus on one task, and the CPUs that run Apple’s tablets are efficient and have enough computing power. So whatever it is you’re doing on an iPad, it will perform it well — within the system’s constraints.
Unique apps make the Apple iPad a more efficient tool for studying. For example, a tablet is much better for reviewing flashcards.
But, having a full-featured word processor, spreadsheet, and presentation software is why many lean towards the laptop side of the debate.
While iPad apps are becoming more versatile, you don’t have all the features in software like Final Cut, AutoCAD, Adobe Creative Suite, and other pro apps.
Coding will be better on a laptop because some IDEs and compilers for many programming languages are unavailable on iPad.
Portability and Battery Life
Apple iPad has a clear advantage in terms of weight and size. The biggest iPad Pro with a 12.9-inch screen weighs 1.51 pounds, while iPad Air hovers around 1 pound. To compare, the lightest 13’’ MacBook Air weighs 2.7 lbs. Most other laptops are in the range of 3.3 to 4.4 pounds.
Even with an additional keyboard, iPad is much more convenient and will take up less space in your backpack. Laptops, on the other hand, are generally more durable and can take more wear and tear.
Having good battery life is super important if you’re lugging your device all day around campus. If you use newer laptops without a dedicated GPU, you can get anywhere between 6 and 14 hours of battery life.
Lower-end and beefier laptops with GPUs for intensive tasks will last less. On the other hand, iPad can give you up to 10 hours of screen time, which can go significantly down for more intensive uses. A solid Android alternative with longer battery life of up to 13 hours is OnePlus Pad that comes with 10.1’’ 144 Hz screen.
Versatility
Out of the box, iPad has less versatility. The laptop has a keyboard and expansion options with USB, HDMI, and an optional card reader.
Buying a costly Magic Keyboard and Apple Pencil is a must if you want to use an iPad for college. There are cheaper third-party options, but the point is that you will need additional hardware.
Generally, I find it much easier to connect a laptop to a monitor via USB-C, use a mouse or additional keyboard, and transfer photos and videos from fast external drives and microSD cards.
Simultaneously, iPad will excel in less performance-based tasks. Apple tablet is more convenient for carrying around, reading textbook PDFs, and making annotations, notes, and creative sketches for artistic majors.
The laptop has a keyboard and expansion options with USB, HDMI, and an optional card reader.
Budget
Apple iPad has several models, and each one has different pricing options.
The most advanced iPad Pro starts at $799 for the 11-inch version and $1099 for the 12.9-inch. Both start with 128 GB of storage.
You can get an iPad Air for $599, and only 64 GB of storage. A 256 GB version costs more than the starting Pro model. Finally, the 10th-gen iPad starts from $499, and you can get older 9th gen from $329.
If reading is your main concern, Amazon Fire Max 11 that runs Fire OS is a cheap and viable alternative. Samsung is main contender to Apple, and their new Samsung Tab S9 is as costly as Apple. OnePlus Pad with price tag of $477 will offer great display and performance.
If we switch over to the laptop side, you can get budget laptops like Chromebooks for around $350, but a decent starting device will cost about $500. The laptop is more affordable if you compare a beefier laptop with iPad Pro and account for must-have accessories like a keyboard and pencil.
The new standard iPad is within the price range of affordable laptops. For the iPad Air price, you can get more than a decent laptop, and iPad Pro is in the category of high-performing laptops.
Ultimately, the specs depend on your needs and are related to your major. Check out our guide to the best laptops for college to find suitable options.
Head-to-Head: Summary of Results
| Laptop | iPad | |
|---|---|---|
| Software | Winner (1) | – |
| Performance | Winner (1) | – |
| Portability and Battery Life | – | Winner (1) |
| Versatility | Winner (1) | – |
| Budget | Winner (1) | – |
| SUMMARY | 4 | 1 |
The Importance of Your Major in Selecting an iPad or a Laptop
The choice between iPad or laptop for students boils down to the major since different programs have different requirements.
Which is better for engineering students
Engineering requires the use of professional desktop applications. With more power, software compatibility, and a bigger screen, laptops are better for AutoCAD, 3D programs, Finite Element Analysis, Matlab, and other specific applications.
If you have a desktop PC at home, iPad is still a great addition for notetaking. If not, check out our best laptop for AutoCAD to find a reliable college companion.
Social studies students don’t need high-performing hardware nor professional and demanding software.
Reading materials and taking notes in classes will work better on an iPad. With the additional keyboard, you can also write papers and create presentations.
Writing long essays and using PowerPoint is easier on a laptop. Even with increasingly better tablet apps, most are stripped down and don’t have all the features.
Which is better for Computer Science students
Computer science programs include coding classes, and a laptop is a far better device for programming.
Students majoring in CS must choose a laptop if they don’t want to work around iPad limitations and use it for coding tasks. While it can be done, you just won’t have the same performance on a tablet.
If you need help finding suitable devices, check out our best gaming and programming laptops guide.
Which is better for accounting, business & finance students
Accounting and finance software runs better on Windows OS. Additionally, you will often open multiple tabs, and a laptop handles them better. Apple iPad Pro has enough computing power, but software compatibility is the main drawback.
Head-to-Head: Summary of Results
| Laptop | iPad | |
|---|---|---|
| Engineering | Winner (1) | – |
| Social studies | – | Winner (1) |
| Computer Science | Winner (1) | – |
| Accounting, business & finance | Winner (1) | – |
| SUMMARY | 3 Points | 1 Points |
The Pros and Cons of Buying an iPad for College
Apple iPad can be a valuable digital assistant to your college journey.
The most significant advantage of the iPad is the ability to seamlessly take notes, annotate materials, and read textbooks and PDFs on a relatively large screen.
Apple iPad 10th generation with third party accessories is within price range of entry and some mid-range laptop models.
iPad Air and especially Pro models don’t have price advantage over laptops. If you opt for iPad Pro with Apple keyboard and Pencil, you will get in range of very competent laptops.
iPads’ inability to run professional, productive, and other apps at total capacity and with all the features is another issue students must consider.
Android tablets are even more challenging in this regard.
Can you replace a laptop with an iPad? Well, that all hinges on your chosen major and the apps you’ll need.
- Pros
- Great screen
- Enough computing power
- Portability
- Long-lasting battery
- Cons
- App limitations
- Within price range of entry and some mid-range laptop models
Conclusion
The primary purpose of digital tools is to make our lives easier. The iPad’s portability, intuitive interface, and unique apps can help immensely with note-taking, reading, and creative work.
A traditional laptop has better software compatibility, multitasking capabilities, and a clean, comfy typing experience. Whether engineering, social studies, computer science, or business, your major plays a decisive role in the iPad vs. laptop quandary.
As you start your college journey, carefully weigh the strengths and limitations of each device. Explore our Laptop Buying Guide: Everything You Should Know to delve deeper into your device options.
